One of the most important considerations before embarking on litigation is whether the potential benefits outweigh the costs involved. Let’s break this down using a typical magistrate court case as an example:
Cost of Litigation
In a magistrate court, the legal fees to obtain a judgment via a full trial can be around RM30,000. This is a significant amount, so it’s crucial to ensure that the debt in question justifies this expense.
Determining the Debt Threshold
From a cost-benefit perspective, it generally makes sense to pursue litigation for debts of at least RM100,000 or more. Here’s why:
Legal Fees: If you are pursuing a debt of RM100,000, the RM30,000 in legal fees represents 30% of the debt. This is a considerable expense, but it can be justified by the amount you stand to recover.
Court Proceedings: Beyond just the initial legal fees, there are additional costs to consider: Interlocutory Applications: These are motions filed during the litigation process and can add to the cost. Appeals: If either party appeals the judgment, further legal fees will be incurred. Enforcement Proceedings: If the debtor does not pay voluntarily after a judgment is obtained, additional costs will be needed to enforce the judgment.
Court Levels and Costs
It’s also important to consider the scale of the debt in relation to the court system:
Magistrate Court: Typically handles smaller claims up to RM100,000. Legal fees typically range from RM 10k-30k to obtain judgment.
Sessions Court: Handles claims up to RM 1 million; legal fees range from RM 15k-60k to obtain judgment.
High Court: For claims above RM 1 million; legal fees range from RM 20k-80k to obtain judgment, and beyond, depending on complexity.
Pre-Court Mediation: A Better Solution?
Before diving into the litigation process, consider pre-court mediation. Here’s why it might be a better solution:
Cost-Effective: Mediation is typically much less expensive than going to court.
Time-Saving: Mediation can resolve disputes faster than the often lengthy court process.
Less Adversarial: Mediation promotes a collaborative approach, which can preserve business relationships.
Confidential: Mediation is a private process, unlike court cases, which are public.
Higher Compliance Rates: Agreements reached through mediation are often more willingly complied with by both parties.
Final Thoughts
Before deciding to litigate, assess the total potential costs versus the debt amount, and whether the debtor even has sufficient cash/assets to enforce against.
This includes considering not just the initial fees but also possible additional expenses from interlocutory applications, appeals, and enforcement. Only when the debt is of sufficient value does it make sense to proceed with litigation.
Pre-court mediation should always be your first option before considering court litigation. It’s cost-effective, quicker, and can save valuable business relationships.
In summary, while litigation can be a powerful tool for debt recovery, it's essential to perform a thorough cost-benefit analysis to ensure it’s worth the investment.
Feel free to get in touch for more legal debt recovery advice!
Comments